Blog

Here’s a quick test I give almost every student.

‍

I read their personal statement and then ask a simple question:

‍

Could someone else write this?

‍

Not “Could someone else write something similar?”

‍

Not “Could another applicant relate to this?”

‍

I mean literally: could you swap the name at the top, change the school, and submit it under someone else’s application without raising eyebrows?

‍

If the answer is yes, the essay isn’t doing its job.

‍

Admissions officers aren’t looking for the best story. They’re looking for your story—the one only you could tell.

‍

Here’s how to audit your application for uniqueness, and how my past students learned to pass the story test:

‍

1. Generic Stories Aren’t Bad—They’re Just Forgettable

‍

Many students write essays that are technically strong, emotionally sincere, and still completely interchangeable.

‍

I have a great recent example that comes to mind: I worked with two pre-med applicants who both wrote about shadowing in the emergency department. Both essays were polished.

‍

But one of the essays could’ve belonged to anyone, focusing on topics like long nights, emotional cases, and growing respect for physicians.

‍

The other student anchored her essay around a single moment: translating for a terrified patient whose dialect didn’t match the hospital interpreter’s. That specific detail made the story hers.

‍

Same setting. Same experience. Completely different impact.

‍

Uniqueness doesn’t come from doing rare things. It comes from noticing rare details.

‍

2. Specificity Is the Shortcut to Originality

‍

You don’t need a dramatic plot twist. You need precision.

‍

I’ve worked with many college applicants over the years, and almost all of them write about leadership at some point in their essays. I remember one whose first draft used phrases like “bringing people together,” “overcoming challenges,” and “learning to lead by example.”

‍

Logical? Sure. Memorable? Not at all.

‍

In our revision, we rewrote the essay around one memorable challenge: the exact text message that caused his club to nearly fall apart, and the awkward meeting where only two people showed up. Suddenly, the essay (or at least the voice/details) couldn’t belong to anyone else.

‍

If your essay contains language that could appear on a motivational poster, it’s too vague.

‍

3. If Your Essay Starts the Same Way as Everyone Else’s, It Ends the Same Way Too

‍

Admissions officers read hundreds of essays that begin with some version of:

“I’ve always wanted to…”

“From a young age…”

“Ever since I was little…”

‍

They’re reasonable openings. But they’re also tired ones.

‍

Recently, one of my dental applicants opened with, “I’ve always been passionate about helping others.” We deleted the entire paragraph and started instead with the sound of a drill failing mid-procedure—a scene from her assisting job that instantly placed the reader inside her world.

‍

She didn’t change, and neither did her motivations. But her new presentation led to a completely different reading experience.

‍

If the opening paragraph could belong to thousands of applicants, the story probably could too. And that means you’ll likely end up concluding with the same generic cliches as others.

‍

4. Voice Matters More Than Vocabulary

‍

Many students confuse sounding “professional” with sounding anonymous.

‍

My law school applicants are often my best writers. Well read, articulate. But that’s only part of the battle. I can recall one who wrote a flawless essay—formally structured, impeccably edited, and completely devoid of personality.

‍

When I asked, “Does this sound like you?” he laughed and said, “Not at all.”

‍

We rewrote it in his natural voice—sharper, slightly self-deprecating, more candid. The grammar stayed strong, but the humanity returned. That version got him into multiple top programs.

‍

Your voice is part of your uniqueness. Don’t edit it out.

‍

5. The Best Essays Make Admissions Officers Feel Like They’ve Met You

‍

When an essay passes the story test, something subtle happens: the reader feels oriented inside a real person’s life.

‍

One super memorable essay came from one of my PT applicants who wrote about growing up above her family’s laundromat. The hum of machines, the smell of detergent, the quiet observation of people’s routines—it was sensory, grounded, unmistakably hers.

‍

Could someone else have written it? Not a chance.

‍

If your essay leaves a sensory or emotional residue, you’re doing it right.

‍

✅ The Story Test Checklist

‍

Could Someone Else Write Your Essay?

‍

Before you submit, run your essay through this checklist. Be honest.

‍

Uniqueness & Specificity

🔲 Could someone with a similar background swap their name into this essay without it raising eyebrows?

🔲 Does my essay include specific details (moments, dialogue, sensory cues, decisions) that belong only to me?

🔲 Do I name one or two concrete moments, rather than summarizing years of experience?

‍

SotrLanguage Audit

🔲 Did I avoid generic phrases like “I’ve always been passionate,” “making a difference,” “helping others,” unless I immediately grounded them in a real example?

🔲 If I highlighted three sentences at random, would they sound like me or like an admissions brochure?

‍

Voice & Personality

🔲 Does this essay sound like how I talk when I’m thoughtful and reflective — not like how I think an applicant should sound?

🔲 Could someone who knows me well recognize me in this writing?

‍

Perspective & Insight

🔲 Do I show how an experience changed the way I think, not just that it happened?

🔲 Is there at least one insight here that only I could have arrived at because of my perspective?

‍

Final Gut Check

🔲 If I removed the title and my name, would this essay still feel unmistakably mine?

🔲 Would an admissions reader finish this feeling like they’d met a real person?

‍

If you checked “no” more than a few times, don’t panic—that’s not failure.

‍

That’s your invitation to dig deeper.